Viscardis, Katharine

The "Orillia Asylum for Idiots" (1861 - 2009), Canada's oldest and largest facility for the care and protection of children and adults with disabilities, was once praised as a beacon of humanitarian progress and described as a "community within a community." Yet, survivors who lived in the facility during the post Second World War period, a time described as the "golden age of children's rights," tell harrowing stories of abuse and neglect. Despite the nation's promise to "put children first" and protect the universal rights of "Canada's children," children incarcerated within the Orillia Asylum were subjected to systemic neglect and cultural discrimination, daily humiliation and dehumanization, and physical, sexual, and emotional abuse. Far from being a place for child protection and care, this dissertation finds that the Orillia Asylum was a site of a multi-faceted and all-encompassing violence, a reality that stands in complete contrast to the grand narrative through which the facility has historically been understood. This dissertation considers how such violence against children could occur for so long in a facility maintained by the state, a state invested in protecting children. It finds that children who were admitted to the Orillia Asylum were not considered to be "Canada's children" at all by virtue of being labelled as "mentally deficient," "feeble-minded," "not-quite-human," and "not-quite-children."

Author Keywords: childhood, disability, Huronia Regional Centre, institutional child abuse, institutional violence, institutionalization