Genetics
Insights from Dictyostelium: Examining the role of cellular stress in Batten disease
The neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses (NCLs), commonly known as Batten disease, are a family of fatal neurodegenerative disorders that primarily affect children. Several subtypes of NCLs have been reported, each being caused by a mutation in a distinct ceroid lipofuscinosis neuronal (CLN) gene; this results in aberrant lysosome function and the accumulation of lipoprotein aggregates (known as ceroid lipofuscin) within cells. Several innate cellular pathways exist to alleviate the stress caused by the buildup of aggregates. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is an essential organelle in this process because it is responsible for maintaining cellular homeostasis through protein production, quality control, and regulating several signalling pathways. The unfolded protein response (UPR) consists of several conserved pathways devoted to attenuating ER stress caused by an accumulation of misfolded proteins or aggregates; at the center of this stress response is GRP78, a molecular chaperone that binds to misfolded proteins to facilitate proper folding. The social amoeba Dictyostelium discoideum is an excellent model system for studying NCLs as it encodes more CLN-like proteins when compared to other classical model organisms (e.g., yeast, worm, fruit fly). In this study, D. discoideum was used to elucidate the effects of ER stress and build an understanding of how cells cope with increased stress. Beyond this, ER stress in D. discoideum models for CLN3 disease and CLN5 disease were evaluated. First and foremost, during the induction of ER stress by tunicamycin, there was an increase in intracellular and extracellular amounts of Grp78 accompanied by an increase in stress-related changes to the ER. Furthermore, models of CLN3 disease and CLN5 disease displayed increased amounts of Grp78 as well as a disrupted ER morphology. Interestingly, wildtype D. discoideum, AX3 cells, treated with tunicamycin displayed a similarly disrupted ER when compared to CLN models. Finally, when subjected to tunicamycin-induced ER stress, these NCL models displayed a trend towards increased Grp78 amounts, however, these cells appear to have a reduced sensitivity to tunicamycin-induced stress compared to wild-type cells. In summary, this study highlights D. discoideum as a model for studying ER stress through the conserved role of Grp78 in the stress response and concludes that an aberrant ER stress underlies the pathology of the NCLs.
Author Keywords: Batten disease, Dictyostelium discoideum, ER stress, GRP78, neuronal ceroid lipofuscinoses (NCLs)
Conservation Genomics of the Lake Superior Caribou
Globally, wildlife populations are experiencing increasing rates of range loss, population decline, and extinction. Caribou (Rangifer tarandus) have experienced dramatic declines in both range and population size across Canada over the past century. Boreal caribou (R. t. caribou), one of twelve Designatable Units, have lost approximately half of their historic range in the last 150 years, particularly along the southern edge of their distribution. Despite this northward contraction, some populations have persisted at the trailing range edge, over 150 km south of the boreal continuous range (BCR) in Ontario, along the coast and near-shore islands of Lake Superior. Better understanding the population structure and evolutionary history of caribou in the Lake Superior range (LSR) could help to inform conservation and management actions, such as the delineation of conservation or management units or translocations between populations. In this thesis, I use whole genome sequences from boreal, eastern migratory and barren-ground caribou sampled in Manitoba, Ontario, and Quebec to investigate evolutionary history and population structure. I discovered that the LSR caribou form a distinct group but also some evidence of gene flow with the BCR. Notably, caribou from the LSR demonstrated relatively high levels of inbreeding (measured as Runs of Homozygosity; ROH) and genetic drift, which may contribute to the differentiation observed between caribou occupying the two ranges. Despite inbreeding, the LSR caribou retained Heterozygosity Rich Regions (HRR). I found genomic structure among caribou populations from the LSR and BCR but found these two ranges had similar demographic histories. My analyses indicate that the LSR caribou display distinct genomic characteristics but share ancestry with the BCR, with historical gene flow between these two ranges. Collectively, this dissertation characterizes the population structure and evolutionary history of caribou from the southernmost range in Ontario, providing key insights for the conservation and management of these small and isolated populations.
The design of DNA-containing biomaterials for forensic science
Access to human blood for forensic research and training in bloodstain pattern analysis (BPA) can be difficult due to many ethical, safety and cost concerns. Mammalian blood alternatives can be sourced, especially from local and willing abattoirs, but some concerns remain, and the added difficulties of high variation and species-specific differences in cellular components pose other issues. Therefore, synthetic alternatives to human blood provide practical options for the BPA community. This thesis explores the use of alginate hydrogels as a base material for forensic blood substitute (FBS) development. Hydrogels are first explored as a suitable environment for DNA stability and functionality and compared to other polymer systems. The ability of DNA to remain intact while undergoing electrospray ionization (ESI) is also investigated. The FBS design focuses on mimicking the fluid properties and genetic capabilities of whole human blood – a material not developed in FBSs previously. ESI was used to develop microparticles (MPs) that serve as cellular components of human blood (the red blood cells – RBCs, and white blood cells – WBCs). The microparticles were ionically crosslinked using calcium to provide small MPs (RBCs) or covalently crosslinked with functional DNA to provide larger WBC-like functional particles. The integration of these novel MPs into alginate-based materials is optimized and their use in BPA scenarios is explored. The FBS is tested in BPA scenarios of dripping experiments, impact patterns, and the ability to extract and amplify the contained DNA. In addition, the stability (or shelf-life) of the FBS was also assessed. The FBS exhibited similar spreading ratios to blood and demonstrated feasibility in use for impact angle (a) determination and impact pattern creation. Importantly, the DNA contained within the FBS could be processed with analogous protocols used in DNA evidence processing, enhancing its applicability to BPA research and training.
Author Keywords: Alginate hydrogels, Bloodstain pattern analysis, Electrospray ionization, Forensic blood substitutes, Forensic materials, Synthetic DNA design
Genes respond in a dose dependent manner to nutritional stress in the freshwater zooplankter, Daphnia pulex
We studied the physiological and molecular responses of lab-grown Daphnia pulex to shifts in dietary (carbon, nitrogen, phosphorus, and cyanobacteria) and growth media (calcium) nutrient supply using a set of potential biomarkers via qPCR. Each examined nutrient had a strong effect on Daphnia mass-specific growth rate, and we found significant dose-dependent effects of treatment level (medium and low) on the gene expression of selected indicator genes. Furthermore, linear discriminant analysis models using different combinations of treatment levels could separate the animals between nutritional treatments with 86-100% prediction accuracy. This would suggest that Daphnia appear able to respond to nutrient limitation by adjusting their growth rate and associated molecular pathways to deal with an insufficient supply of nutrients. While this study provides valuable information regarding Daphnia's ability to adjust physiological and molecular processes under controlled laboratory conditions, more validation needs to be conducted before applying these potential biomarkers to wild populations to assess the type and intensity of nutritional stress.
The ecology and evolution of animal migration – an integrative approach to the drivers of phenotypic variation
Animal migrations are ubiquitous and one of the most threatened ecological processes globally. Because of the multifaceted nature of migration – seasonal movements between home ranges – it can be difficult to tease apart the underlying mechanisms influencing this behaviour. It is necessary to understand these mechanisms, not only to deepen our fundamental understanding of migration in animals, but also because migrations in many species are vulnerable to environmental change. In Chapter 2, I first systematically identify the broad proximate drivers of migration and offer generalities across vertebrate taxa. I quantitatively reviewed 45 studies and extracted 132 observations of effect sizes for internal and external proximate drivers that influenced migration propensity. Through this meta-analysis, I found that internal and external drivers had a medium and large effect, respectively, on migration propensity. Predator abundance and predation risk had a large effect on migration propensity, as did individual behaviour. Of the studies that examined genetic divergence between migrant and resident populations, 64% found some genetic divergence between groups. In Chapter 3, I explore the genetic basis for migration and identified genes associated with migration direction from pooled genome-wide scans on a population of 233 migrating female mule deer (Odocoileus hemionus) where I identified genomic regions including FITM1, a gene linked to the formation of lipids, and DPPA3, a gene linked to epigenetic modifications of the maternal line. These results are consistent with the underlying genetic basis for a migratory trait which contributes to the additive genetic variance influencing migratory behaviours and can affect the adaptive potential of a species. Finally, in Chapter 4 I used a pedigree-free quantitative genetic approach to estimate heritability and sources of environmental variation in migration distance, timing, and movement rate of the same population of mule deer. I found low heritability for broad patterns of migration timing, and greater variation in heritability for behaviours during migration, with low heritability for distance and duration and high heritability for movement rate along the route. Insights into the genetic and environmental sources of variation for migration are critical both for the eco-evolutionary dynamics of migration behaviour, and for the conservation of species whose migrations may be vulnerable to environmental change. My thesis reveals that broad patterns of migration are driven largely by environmental effects while within these broad patterns, migration behaviour is driven to a measurable degree by genetic variation.
Author Keywords: heritability, migration, Odocoileus hemionus, reduced representation sequencing, whole genome sequencing
Gene flow directionality and functional genetic variation among Ontario, Canada Ursus americanus populations.
Rapidly changing landscapes introduce challenges for wildlife management, particularly for large mammal populations with long generation times and extensive spatial requirements. Understanding how these populations interact with heterogeneous landscapes aids in predicting responses to further environmental change. In this thesis, I profile American black bears using microsatellite loci and pooled whole-genome sequencing. These data characterize gene flow directionality and functional genetic variation to understand patterns of dispersal and local adaptation; processes key to understanding vulnerability to environmental change. I show dispersal is positively density-dependent, male biased, and influenced by food productivity gradients suggestive of source-sink dynamics. Genomic comparison of bears inhabiting different climate and forest zones identified variation in genes related to the cellular response to starvation and cold. My thesis demonstrates source-sink dynamics and local adaption in black bears. Population management must balance dispersal to sustain declining populations against the risk of maladaptation under future scenarios of environmental change.
Author Keywords: American black bear, Dispersal, Functional Genetic Variation, Gene Flow Directionality, Genomics, Local Adaptation
Nutrigenomics of Daphnia: Examining effects of nutrients on the Daphnia pulex transcriptome and identifying nutritional phenotypes
Organismal nutrition lies at the interface between biotic and abiotic factors in an ecosystem, dictating the transfer of energy and nutrients across trophic levels. Our ability to detect nutritional limitation in consumers is reliant on a priori knowledge of dietary history due to our inability to differentiate nutrient stress based on body-wide responses. Molecular physiological responses are increasingly being used to measure physiological stress with high levels of specificity due to the specific modes of action ecological stressors have on organismal molecular physiology. Because animal consumers respond to varying nutrient supplies by up- and down-regulating nutrient-specific metabolic pathways, we can quantify nutritional status by quantifying the expression of those pathways. Here I present an investigation into the use of transcriptomics to detect nutritional stress in the keystone aquatic herbivore, Daphnia pulex, I use RNAseq and quantitative PCR (qPCR) identify nutritional indicator genes. I found that nutritional status could be determined with 100% accuracy with just ten genes. Additionally, the functional annotation of those genes uncovered previously unidentified responses to dietary stress. Further testing and validation of the selected indicator genes is required however these findings have the potential to revolutionize our ability to measure and monitor consumer nutritional stress.
Author Keywords: Biomarkers, Daphnia, Gene expression, Nutrigenomics, Nutritional ecology, RNAseq
Islands, ungulates, and ice: the response of caribou to a changing environment
Central to wildlife conservation and management is the need for refined, spatially explicit knowledge on the diversity and distribution of species and the factors that drive those patterns. This is especially vital as anthropogenic disturbance threatens rapid large-scale change, even in the most remote areas of the planet. My dissertation examines theinfluence of land- and sea-scape heterogeneity on patterns of genetic differentiation, diversity, and broad-scale distributions of island-dwelling ungulates in the Arctic Archipelago. First, I investigated genetic differentiation among island populations of Peary caribou (Rangifer tarandus pearyi) in contrast to continental migratory caribou (Rangifer tarandus) and evaluated whether genetic exchange among Peary caribou island populations was limited by the availability of sea ice – both now and in the future. Differentiation among both groups was best explained by geodesic distance, revealing sea ice as an effective platform for Peary caribou movement and gene flow. With future climate warming, substantial reductions in sea ice extent were forecast which significantly increased resistance to caribou movement, particularly in summer and fall. Second, I assessed genetic population structure and diversity of northern caribou and deciphered how Island Biogeography Theory (IBT) and Central Marginal Hypothesis (CMH) could act in an archipelago where isolation is highly variable due to the dynamics of sea ice. Genetic differentiation among continental and island populations was low to moderate. In keeping with IBT and CMH, island-dwelling caribou displayed lower genetic diversity compared to mainland and mainland migratory herds; the size of islands (or population range) positively influenced genetic diversity, while distance-to-mainland and fall ice-free coastlines negatively influenced genetic diversity. Hierarchical structure analysis revealed multiple units of caribou diversity below the species level. Third, I shifted my focus to the terrestrial landscape and explored the elements governing species-environment relationships. Using species distribution models, I tested the response of caribou and muskoxen to abiotic versus abiotic + biotic predictors, and included distance to heterospecifics as a proxy for competitive interactions. Models that included biotic predictors outperformed models with abiotic predictors alone, and biotic predictors were most important when identifying habitat suitability for both ungulates. Further, areas of high habitat suitability for caribou and muskoxen were largely disjunct, limited in extent, and mainly outside protected areas. Finally, I modelled functional connectivity for two genetically and spatially disjunct groups of island-dwelling caribou. For High Arctic caribou, natural and anthropogenic features impeded gene flow (isolation-by-resistance); for Baffin Island caribou we found panmixia with absence of isolation-by-distance. Overall, my dissertation demonstrates the varying influences of contemporary land- and sea-scape heterogeneity on the distribution, diversity and differentiation of Arctic ungulates and it highlights the vulnerability of island-dwelling caribou to a rapidly changing Arctic environment.
Author Keywords: Circuitscape, connectivity, Island Biogeography, landscape genetics, population structure, species distribution models
Genetic Networks to Investigate Structure and Connectivity of Caribou at Multiple Spatial and Temporal Scales
Understanding genetic structure, connectivity, and movement of a species iscritical to management and conservation. Genetic network approaches allow the analysis of genetic information with flexibility and few prior assumptions. In chapter one, I tested the ability of individual-based genetic networks to detect fine-scale structure and connectivity in relation to sampling efforts. My findings revealed individual-based genetic networks can detect fine-scale genetic structure of caribou when using 15 highly variable microsatellite loci. Sampling levels less than 50% of the estimated population size resulted in highly disconnected networks which did not allow for accurate structure analysis; however community detection algorithms were robust in grouping closely related individuals despite low sampling. In chapter two, I used individual-based and population-based genetic networks to investigate structure, connectivity, and movement of caribou across a large study area in Western Canada. A community detection algorithm partitioned the population-based genetic network at multiple spatial scales which uncovered patterns of hierarchical genetic structure and highlighted patterns of gene flow. The hierarchical population structure results aligned with the known distribution of different caribou Designatable Units (DUs) and additional structure was found within each DU. Furthermore, individual-based networks that were constructed with a subset of samples from the Mackenzie Mountains region of the Northwest Territories revealed patterns of long-distance movement and high connectivity across the region.
Author Keywords: Biological Conservation, Caribou, Community Detection, Connectivity, Genetic Networks, Structure
SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL GENETIC STRUCTURE OF WOLVERINE POPULATIONS
Habitat loss and fragmentation can disrupt population connectivity, resulting in small, isolated populations and low genetic variability. Understanding connectivity patterns in space and time is critical in conservation and management planning, especially for wide-ranging species in northern latitudes where habitats are becoming increasingly fragmented. Wolverines (Gulo gulo) share similar life history traits observed in large-sized carnivores, and their low resiliency to disturbances limits wolverine persistence in modified or fragmented landscapes - making them a good indicator species for habitat connectivity. In this thesis, I used neutral microsatellite and mitochondrial DNA markers to investigate genetic connectivity patterns of wolverines for different temporal and spatial scales. Population genetic analyses of individuals from North America suggested wolverines west of James Bay in Canada are structured into two contemporary genetic clusters: an extant cluster at the eastern periphery of Manitoba and Ontario, and a northwestern core cluster. Haplotypic composition, however, suggested longstanding differences between the extant eastern periphery and northwestern core clusters. Phylogeographic analyses across the wolverine's Holarctic distribution supported a postglacial expansion from a glacial refugium near Beringia. Although Approximate Bayesian computations suggested a west-to-east stepping-stone divergence pattern across North America, a mismatch distribution indicated a historic bottleneck event approximately 400 generations ago likely influenced present-day patterns of haplotype distribution. I also used an individual-based genetic distance measure to identify landscape features potentially influencing pairwise genetic distances of wolverines in Manitoba and Ontario. Road density and mean spring snow cover were positively associated with genetic distances. Road density was associated with female genetic distance, while spring snow cover variance was associated with male genetic distance. My findings suggest that northward expanding anthropogenic disturbances have the potential to affect genetic connectivity. Overall, my findings suggest that (1) peripheral populations can harbour genetic variants not observed in core populations - increasing species genetic diversity; (2) historic bottlenecks can alter the genetic signature of glacial refugia, resulting in a disjunct distribution of unique genetic variants among contemporary populations; (3) increased temporal resolution of the individual-based genetic distance measure can help identify landscape features associated with genetic connectivity within a population, which may disrupt landscape connectivity.
Author Keywords: conservation genetics, Holarctic species, landscape genetics, peripheral population, phylogeography, wolverine