Eimers, Catherine
Short-term biogeochemical response of hardwood forest soils to wood ash additions in central Ontario
The accelerated recovery of base-poor soils from the legacy effects of acidic deposition may be possible by applying industrial wood ash as a soil amendment. Wood ash may be an effective soil amendment due to its high alkalinity and concentrations of several essential nutrients, such as calcium, magnesium, potassium, and phosphorus, that are retained after the volatilization of the parent material. However, wood ash can also contain trace amounts of metals that could be released into the soil and soil solution. The short-term (<3 years) biogeochemical response of soils, microbial communities, and sugar maple (Acer saccharum Marsh.) trees were assessed following wood ash application at Porridge Lake, Ontario. The study design consisted of five blocks containing three treatment plots each (2.5, 5.0, 7.5 Mg ha-1) and a control. Soil solution pH, base cation, and trace metal concentrations were monitored for three years, using tension lysimeters at depths of 30 and 60 cm and zero-tension lysimeters for forest floor percolate within each plot. In the last year of the trial, soil, foliage, and fine root samples were collected and analyzed for trace elements. Also, soil samples were analyzed for the abundance of 16S and ITS DNA through metabarcoding to ascertain the microbial response to wood ash. Significant changes in soil solution pH were measured within the forest floor horizon in the first year of the trial. Significant increases in calcium (Ca), magnesium (Mg) and calcium/aluminum (Ca/Al) ratios were also observed in the second year of the trial, along with decreases in dissolved organic carbon (DOC), sulphate (SO4) and nitrate (NO3) in the LFH horizon. By the third year of the trial, significant increases in soil solution pH and potassium (K) concentrations and decreases in Al were observed to a depth of 30 cm. Changes in trace metal concentrations in soil water were notably variable, with concentrations of chromium, copper, lead, nickel, and selenium remaining unresponsive, whereas concentrations of cadmium, manganese and zinc decreased by the third year. The metalloid arsenic showed a significant increase in the third year of the trial but remained below regulatory guidelines, similar to all other trace metals. Soil measurements conducted in the third year of the trial showed positive pH responses in the FH horizon and increases in Ca and Mg in the Ah and Bm soil horizons, but foliar base cation and metal concentrations were unchanged. Diversity analysis on the soil prokaryotic and eukaryotic groups indicated increased bacterial alpha diversity in the FH horizon and bacterial dominance in the litter horizon. Analysis of relative abundance at the phylum level for prokaryotes and at the order for eukaryotes did not indicate any compositional shifts due to the wood ash treatments. Changes in the length and diameter of sugar maple and mycorrhizal fine root may point to pH shock being an issue at higher ash doses. The results from this study indicate that wood ash has a strong ameliorative effect on soil properties and does not pose a risk to soil communities.
Author Keywords: DNA, mycorrhizae, soil acidication, soil amendments, soil solution, sugar maple
Soil health and soil microbial responses to cash crop management in Ontario
In Ontario, farmers commonly use a MZ (Maize (Zea mays L.))-SB (Soybean (Glycine max))/WW (Winter wheat (Triticum aestivum)) – CC (mixed cover crop) rotation to maximize economic benefits. This study aimed to investigate the short-term impacts of the crop rotation phases and their associated management practices in this diversified cash crop rotation on soil health and the abundance of nitrogen (N)-cycling soil microbial communities (SMCs). Additionally, the abundance of N-cycling SMCs and plant-available N in both surface (0-5 cm) and rooting zone (5-15 cm) depths were characterized in tile-drained (TD) and non-TD fields. In the present study, soils collected under the CC phase had the highest labile carbon levels (10-17% higher) and water-stable aggregates (35-50% higher) compared to the other two crop phases. Lower nitrifying (amoA) gene abundances and soil NO3--N levels were observed in the CC phase compared to the MZ and SB-WW phases, suggesting a potential for decreased nitrification in the CC phase. The presence of SB potentially influenced the soil N concentration in the subsequent WW phase likely due to the release of symbiotically fixed N in the SB-WW phase. Further, higher amoA abundances and NO3--N in the SB-WW phase imply a potential for increased nitrification in the SB-WW phase. Additionally, higher amoA/nosZI and nirS+nirK/nosZI ratios were observed in the MZ phase than in SB-WW and CC phases, suggesting a potential capacity for increased N2O emissions from the reactions mediated by N-cycling SMCs in soils planted to MZ during fall sampling days. In the TD and NTD field study, higher NO3--N levels were observed in TD-SB-WW fields at 5-15 cm vs. 0-5 cm depths, which was possibly facilitated by tile drainage. The TD-CC fields displayed higher nosZI gene abundances and lower nirS+nirK/nosZI abundance ratios, suggesting a greater potential capacity for decreased N2O emissions in soils planted to CCs during the spring sampling days. When examining changes in plant available N by soil depth, reduced downward movement of NO3- through shallow soil depths (0-15 cm depth) was observed in the CC phase compared to cash crops. This short-term study highlights the potential contribution of the CC phase, particularly within TD agricultural fields, for improving soil health and reducing potential N2O emissions. Together, these results suggest that management-associated differences in crop rotation phases have temporary effects on soil health and the abundance of SMCs. Future studies linking N-cycling SMC's potential activity and field-scale N2O fluxes will provide a better insight into the longer-term sustainability of Ontario's cash crop management systems.
Author Keywords: denitrification, maize-soybean-winter wheat- cover crop rotation, nitrification, soil depth, Sustainable agriculture, tile-drainage
Effects of tile drainage, seasonality, and cash crop rotation on edge-of-field nitrogen and phosphorus losses from southern Ontario Watersheds
Eutrophication is an ongoing global problem and agriculture is an important non-point source of nutrient loading. Specifically, nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) losses from agricultural landscapes continue to drive water quality issues. In southern Ontario, agriculture has intensified in recent decades, with major expansions of cash crop production and extensive tile drainage (TD). Through intensive monitoring of 12 tile outlets draining operational fields under the conventional corn-soybean-wheat rotation, this study examined differences in measured and volume-weighted total P, total N, and nitrate-N concentrations and loads over 28 months (October 2020- April 2023) amongst crop covers and between growing (GS; May – September) and non-growing seasons (NGS; October – April). Nitrogen concentrations (i.e., TN and NO3-N) in TD eluent were consistently high both between seasons and were found to be significantly highest from winter wheat (WW) fields in the NGS, and corn fields in the GS. Volume-weighted TP concentrations were not significantly different either amongst crop covers or between seasons, although TP losses tended to be highest from the cover crop (CC) fields in the NGS. Differences in N and P losses between years and amongst crop covers were attributed to differences in legacy soil nutrients, the establishment and decomposition of over-winter cover crops, and physical soil properties. The results of this study can inform agricultural management by addressing the urgent need for improved information around the relationship between agricultural practices and nutrient losses, especially in the NGS.
Author Keywords: Best management practices, Crop rotation, Over-winter cover crops, Seasonality, Tile drainage, Water quality
Short-Term Impacts of Agricultural Land Use Change on Soil Health and Nitrogen Cycling Microbial Communities
Glyphosate burndown and tillage, followed by the cultivation of cash crops, are frequently used techniques in LUC from perennial cropping systems (PS) to annual cropping systems (AS). Agricultural LUC can result in the loss of soil nitrogen (N) via emission of nitrous oxide (N2O), a potent greenhouse gas (GHG). The purpose of this thesis is to investigate the short-term impacts of agricultural LUC from PS to AS on soil health parameters and the nitrogen (N)-cycling bacterial communities responsible for nitrification and denitrification processes that result in the emission of N2O. The study field site was in Stone Mills, Ontario and comprised of four fields: two annual cropping systems were regularly cultivated for cash crops (AS), and two perennial cropping systems had not been cultivated for cash crops for over 50 years (PS). One PS was left intact while the other PS was subjected to LUC (converted system [CS]) from PS to AS within the study period. The results of this study indicate that PS promotes soil health, as illustrated through higher soil organic matter % (2.3 ± 0.2 %), beta-glucosidase activity (0.41 ± 0.04 mmol g-1 dry soil h-1), and N-acetylglucosaminidase activity (0.18 ± 0.03 mmol g-1 dry soil h-1). The PS soils exhibited higher nitrifier (6.0 0.3 log10 copies per g dry soil) and denitrifier (nirS, nirK and nosZI: 7.8 0.05, 8.1 0.1 and 5.0 0.1 log10 copies per g dry soil, respectively) gene abundances compared to AS (amoA, nirS, nirK and nosZI: 5.7 0.1, 7.7 0.04, 7.9 0.1 and 4.8 0.1 log10 copies per g dry soil, respectively). Moreover, LUC from PS to AS deteriorated soil health parameters and significantly decreased the nosZI/16S rRNA gene ratio, leading to potential N loss through N2O emissions. A laboratory incubation study revealed that the use of N-containing fertilizer in conjunction with easily metabolized C cumulatively resulted in 64.2% increase in N2O and 42.1% increase in CO2 fluxes in AS soils compared to PS soils. The AS soils also produced 69.8% more N2O and 13.4% more CO2 when compared to CS soils. The results suggest that the availability of C and N promote R-strategists, leading to increased production of CO2 and N2O. Additionally, results also suggest that LUC mediates fluxes depending on resource availability. The findings of this research demonstrate the significance of LUC in shaping N-cycling microbial communities and GHG emissions, emphasizing the importance of transitioning towards less intensive management practices to ensure the long-term sustainability of the agri-food system.
Author Keywords: annual, denitrification, greenhouse gas, laboratory incubation, nitrification, perennial
Evaluating the Relationships Between Land Use and Stream Nutrient and Chloride Concentrations Across Southern Ontario
Agricultural and urban land uses have been linked to the recent resurgence of eutrophication and salinization issues in the lower Great Lakes. This thesis examined the relationship between watershed land use and stream nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N), total phosphorus (TP), and chloride (Cl) concentrations across southern Ontario. Using a self-organizing map analysis, the watersheds were classified into eight distinct spatial clusters, representing four agricultural, two urban, and two natural clusters. Agricultural clusters under intensive row crop agriculture exhibited NO3-N and TP concentrations up to twelve and five times higher, respectively, than the most natural-dominated cluster. Urban clusters had Cl concentrations up to nine times greater than the natural-dominated clusters. Three agricultural land use practices, namely continuous corn-soybean rotation, synthetic fertilizer application, and tile drainage, were positively correlated with stream NO3-N concentrations, whereas Cl concentrations increased with urban area and human population density. This thesis also characterized sampling trends of the provincial stream water quality monitoring program and found that sampling frequency has declined since the mid-1990s, while current sites are monitored almost exclusively during the ice-free period. Sampling year-round is critical to capture seasonal variations in NO3-N and Cl, while sampling across a full range of flow conditions is important for describing TP. Exclusion of sampling sites in close proximity of downstream municipal wastewater treatment plants and greenhouses can help isolate and better understand water quality impacts of non-point sources. Although intensive agricultural watersheds in southwestern Ontario draining into Lake Erie remain a priority for research and management, regions experiencing row crop expansion such as along the northern shore of Lake Ontario as well as rapidly urbanizing areas require further attention as these land use shifts will likely increase stream NO3-N and Cl concentrations, placing further pressure on water resources in the lower Great Lakes.
Author Keywords: Chloride, Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Self-organizing map, Southern Ontario, Water quality
The Effects of Agricultural Land Use Change on Nitrogen and Phosphorus in North Shore Lake Ontario Tributaries
Row crop agriculture and associated land use practices including tile drainage and conservation tillage have been cited as a probable cause of re-emerging eutrophication in the lower Great Lakes. In this thesis, I sought to quantify and evaluate the effect of agricultural land cover and land use changes on total phosphorus (TP) and nitrate-nitrogen (NO3-N) concentrations and export in north shore Lake Ontario tributaries. This included (a) a long-term data analyses at 12 large watersheds (47 to 278 km²) using historical land cover and water quality data (1971-2010), and (b) a space-for-time study examining 12 small sub-catchments (< 8 km²) with majority (> 50%) row crop, pasture, or forest cover. Concentrations of TP were greatest in urbanized watersheds and declined particularly during the first decades of the study period, while NO3-N concentrations were greatest and steadily increased in agricultural catchments with increasing row crop cover. The space-for-time approach revealed that TP concentrations were similar across agricultural land uses and that export was most dependent on runoff. Meanwhile, NO3-N concentrations and export were greatest in row crop catchments and were positively related to row crop area. These results suggest that increases in row crop cover and associated agricultural practices including increased nutrient amendments and tile drainage may be responsible for increased NO3-N concentrations and export in northern Lake Ontario tributaries.
Author Keywords: agriculture, Lake Ontario, nitrogen, phosphorus, streams, Water quality
Seasonal variation in nutrient and particulate inputs and outputs at an urban stormwater pond in Peterborough, Ontario
Stormwater ponds (SWPs) are a common feature in new urban developments where they are designed to minimize runoff peaks from impervious surfaces and retain particulate matter. As a consequence, SWPs can be efficient at retaining particle-bound nutrients, but may be less efficient at retaining nutrients that are present primarily in the dissolved form, like nitrogen (N). However, the forms of nutrients (e.g. particulate vs. dissolved) likely differ with hydrologic and seasonal conditions and few studies have examined year-round differences in nutrient forms and concentrations at urban SWPs. In order to contrast total suspended solids (TSS), phosphorus (P) and nitrogen (N) levels between low and high flow conditions, sampling was conducted at an urban SWP in Peterborough, ON between November 2012 and October 2013. Only an increase in TSS levels at the outflow between low and high flow conditions was observed, as well as a decrease in TSS levels at the outflow compared to Inflow 1 under low flow conditions. Nitrate-N (NO3-N) was the dominant form of N entering the pond under all flow conditions, whereas the fraction of total-P (TP) that was particulate increased under high flow conditions. Nevertheless, the dissolved fraction of TP was consistently high in these urban inlets. Only NO3-N was significantly greater in the inflows than outflow and only under low flow conditions. Increases in the proportions of organic-N and ammonium-N
in the outlet suggest that biological processing is important for N retention.
Author Keywords: nitrogen, Ontario, phosphorus, stormwater ponds, total suspended solids
Hydroclimatic and spatial controls on stream nutrient export from forested catchments
Winter nutrient export from forested catchments is extremely variable from year-to-year and across the landscape of south-central Ontario. Understanding the controls on this variability is critical, as what happens during the winter sets up the timing and nature of the spring snowmelt, the major period of export for water and nutrients from seasonally snow-covered forests. Furthermore, winter processes are especially vulnerable to changes in climate, particularly to shifts in precipitation from snow to rain as air temperatures rise. The objective of this thesis was to assess climatic and topographic controls on variability in stream nutrient export from a series of forested catchments in south-central Ontario. The impacts of climate on the timing and magnitude of winter stream nutrient export, with particular focus on the impact of winter rain-on-snow (ROS) events was investigated through a) analysis of long-term hydrological, chemical and meteorological records and b) high frequency chemical and isotopic measurements of stream and snow samples over two winters. The relationship between topography and variability in stream chemistry among catchments was investigated through a) a series of field and laboratory incubations to measure rates and discern controls on nitrogen mineralization and nitrification and b) analysis of high resolution spatial data to assess relationships between topographic metrics and seasonal stream chemistry. Warmer winters with more ROS events were shown to shift the bulk of nitrate (NO3-N) export earlier in the winter at the expense of spring export; this pattern was not observed in other nutrients [i.e. dissolved organic carbon (DOC), total phosphorus (TP), sulphate (SO4), calcium (Ca)]. Hydrograph separation revealed the majority of ROS flow came from baseflow, but the NO3-N concentrations in rainfall and melting snow were so high that the majority of NO3-N export was due to these two sources. Other nutrient concentrations did not show such a great separation between sources, and thus event export of these nutrients was not as great. Proportionally, catchments with varying topography responded similarly to ROS events, but the absolute magnitude of export varied substantially, due to differences in baseflow NO3-N concentrations. Field and laboratory incubations revealed differences in rates of net NO3-N production between wetland soils and upland soils, suggesting that topographic differences amongst catchments may be responsible for differences in baseflow NO3-N. Spatial analysis of digital elevation models revealed strong relationships between wetland coverage and DOC and dissolved organic nitrogen (DON) concentrations in all seasons, but relationships between topography and NO3-N were often improved by considering only the area within 50 or 100m of the stream channel. This suggests nutrient cycling processes occurring near the stream channel may exert a stronger control over NO3-N stream outflow chemistry. Overall, topography and climate exert strong controls over spatial and temporal variability in stream chemistry at forested catchments; it is important to consider the interaction of these two factors when predicting the effects of future changes in climate or deposition.
Author Keywords: biogeochemistry, forest, nitrate, south-central Ontario, stream chemistry, winter
ADAPT: An Automated Decision Support Tool For Adaptation To Climate Change-Driven Floods Predicted From A Multiscale And Multi-Model Framework
This thesis focuses on the design of a modelling framework consisting of loose-coupling of a sequence of spatial and process models and procedures necessary to predict future flood events for the years 2030 and 2050 in Tabasco Mexico. Temperature and precipitation data from the Hadley Centers Coupled Model (HadCM3), for those future years were downscaled using the Statistical Downscaling Model (SDSM4.2.9). These data were then used along with a variety of digital spatial data and models (current land use, soil characteristics, surface elevation and rivers) to parameterize the Soil Water Assessment Tool (SWAT) model and predict flows. Flow data were then input into the Hydrological Engineering Centers-River Analysis System (HEC-RAS) model. This model mapped the areas that are expected to be flooded based on the predicted flow values. Results from this modelling sequence generate images of flood extents, which are then ported to an online tool (ADAPT) for display. The results of this thesis indicate that with current prediction of climate change the city of Villahermosa, Tabasco, Mexico, and the surrounding area will experience a substantial amount of flooding. Therefore there is a need for adaptation planning to begin immediately.
Author Keywords: Adaptation Planning, Climate Change, Extreme Weather Events, Flood Planning, Simulation Modelling
CO2 dynamics of tundra ponds in the low-Arctic Northwest Territories, Canada
Extensive research has gone into measuring changes to the carbon storage capacity of Arctic terrestrial environments as well as large water bodies in order to determine a carbon budget for many regions across the Arctic. Inland Arctic waters such as small lakes and ponds are often excluded from these carbon budgets, however a handful of studies have demonstrated that they can often be significant sources of carbon to the atmosphere. This study investigated the CO2 cycling of tundra ponds in the Daring Lake area, Northwest Territories, Canada (64°52'N, 111°35'W), to determine the role ponds have in the local carbon cycle.
Floating chambers, nondispersive infrared (NDIR) sensors and headspace samples were used to estimate carbon fluxes from four selected local ponds. Multiple environmental, chemical and meteorological parameters were also monitored for the duration of the study, which took place during the snow free season of 2013.
Average CO2 emissions for the two-month growing season ranged from approximately -0.0035 g CO2-C m-2 d-1 to 0.12 g CO2-C m-2 d-1. The losses of CO2 from the water bodies in the Daring Lake area were approximately 2-7% of the CO2 uptake over vegetated terrestrial tundra during the same two-month period.
Results from this study indicated that the production of CO2 in tundra ponds was positively influenced by both increases in air temperature, and the delivery of carbon from their catchments. The relationship found between temperature and carbon emissions suggests that warming Arctic temperatures have the potential to increase carbon emissions from ponds in the future.
The findings in this study did not include ebullition gas emissions nor plant mediated transport, therefore these findings are likely underestimates of the total carbon emissions from water bodies in the Daring Lake area. This study emphasizes the need for more research on inland waters in order to improve our understanding of the total impact these waters may have on the Arctic's atmospheric CO2 concentrations now and in the future.
Author Keywords: Arctic, Arctic Ponds, Carbon dioxide, Carbon Fluxes, Climate Change, NDIR sensor